Login

Signup

Policy Briefs presented on the margins of the AU Mid-Year Coordination Meeting at the seminar

“The African Peace Mission and Ukraine Peace Formula: Strategic Engagements on Regional Security, Nuclear Safety, and Human Rights”

Date: 18 July 2024
Place: Accra, Ghana

Experts from various institutions collaboratively developed three policy briefs in support of the African Peace Mission and Ukraine Peace Formula. 

These briefs address UN reform, the safety of nuclear power stations, and the protection of children during armed conflicts. 

The recommendations were presented at the seminar “The African Peace Mission and Ukraine Peace Formula: Strategic Engagements on Regional Security, Nuclear Safety, and Human Rights” ahead of the African Union Mid-Year Coordination Meeting taking place on 18-21 July in Accra.

Policy Brief Speakers

Post-Event Release

Side-event “The African Peace Mission and Ukraine Peace Formula: Strategic Engagements on Regional Security, Nuclear Safety, and Human Rights” before the upcoming AU Mid-Year Coordination Meeting 

 

Date: 18 July 2024

Place: Accra, Ghana 

 

A group of Ghanaian, South African, and Ukrainian civil society organisations is calling on the African Union and delegates of African states to lead the way for safer nuclear energy development, better protection of children, and fewer opportunities for nuclear-armed states to threaten disarmed nations, through the reform of the United Nations Security Council.

Experts from various institutions collaboratively developed three policy briefs in support of the African Peace Mission and Ukraine Peace Formula. These briefs address UN reform, the safety of nuclear power stations, and the protection of children during armed conflicts. The recommendations were presented at the seminar “The African Peace Mission and Ukraine Peace Formula: Strategic Engagements on Regional Security, Nuclear Safety, and Human Rights” ahead of the African Union Mid-Year Coordination Meeting taking place on 18-21 July in Accra.

The experts specifically, call on the AU and African states to:

1. Initiate UN reform that reduces the power of the veto-right.

This means empowering the United Nations General Assembly to overrule a veto with a 2/3 majority. 

Ukraine’s experience showed that while the majority of countries condemned the Russian invasion of Ukraine (over 141 states), Russia could block any UN action to defend Ukraine by using its veto at the UNSC. Changing the veto power distribution would help ensure global peace if any veto-holding country starts military aggression against another state.

The mechanism for a provisional review and amendment of the UN Charter is also built in Article 109, which enables a special “Charter Review Conference” to be convened by a two-thirds majority of the UN General Assembly and a single vote from the nine-member Security Council.

Such a vote cannot be vetoed by the permanent members and would be relatively democratic, since Article 109 states that “each member of the United Nations shall have one vote”.

 

2. Act immediately to uphold international obligations on non-proliferation and stop the aggression of nuclear-armed states against denuclearised nations. 

In 1994, Ukraine gave up its nuclear arsenal, the third largest in the world at the time, in exchange for security assurances from the USA, the UK, and Russia. Russian aggression against Ukraine endangers the core of international non-proliferation, increasing the risk of non-nuclear nations pursuing their own weapons of mass destruction. In 2023, global military spending increased by 7%, which means less funds for socio-economic development around the world. 

 

3. Protect peaceful nuclear power plants by approving new binding international legislation that prohibits military attacks on nuclear facilities. Nuclear technology is a potential option to support African economic development. 

The occupation of the largest operational nuclear power plant in Europe by Russian military forces, in violation of all nuclear safety principles, must be stopped and never repeated. 

Many African countries recently voted for a UN resolution calling on Russia to remove its military forces from the Ukrainian nuclear power station.

 

4. Recognise that children are the first victims of military conflict. As of June 2024, Russia has unlawfully and forcibly deported 19,546 Ukrainian children.

Post 2022, Russia has approved a new legislation allowing the change of citizenship, name, surname, and date of birth of Ukrainian children without parental consent. Ukrainian children have been sent to 57 regions of Russia, with some already adopted into Russian families. Despite support from UN institutions, the International Red Cross, religious leaders such as the Vatican, and individual states like Qatar, only 388 children have been returned in nearly three years. There is a lack of effective mechanisms for their return [https://childrenofwar.gov.ua/en/]. 

 

5. We call on the Africa Peace Mission to continue working on the points listed in this statement and to act on implementing the above

Russia militarily invaded Ukraine in 2014, and with the lack of international response to its aggression, it escalated its military invasion to a full-scale war in 2022. The collaborative platforms for experts have been initiated by the Institute of Justice and Reconciliation, the Desmond and Leah Tutu Legacy Foundation, the Democratic Institute Foundation (DIF), and the Ukrainian Association of South Africa (UAZA). More than twenty experts from different fields are partnering for a better future for the African continent.  

 

For more information about the statement or the initiative please contact Dzvinka Kachur [email protected]

Policy Briefs Presentation

Russia’s Strategy to Fix Its Demographic Crisis Using Ukrainian Children
We Have A Crisis Of Multilateralism. Is There A Window Of Opportunity?
Is There A Way To Return Abducted Ukrainian Children Home?
We Need To Reform The United Nations Security Council
Are We On The Edge Of Nuclear Disaster?

Draft Policy Briefs Presented at Multiple Academic Institutions

South African and Ukrainian experts suggest next steps for the Africa Peace Mission: Regional Security, Nuclear Safety and Deportation of childrenPlanned events 11-15 March 2024:

11 March (Monday): 14h00 – 16h00, Seminar South African Insights on Ukraine’s Path to Peace: Regional Security, Nuclear Safety, and Human Rights Perspectives”, Stellenbosch University;

12 March (Tuesday): 9h30 – 12h30, Seminar “South African Insights on Ukraine’s Path to Peace: Regional Security, Nuclear Safety, and Human Rights Perspectives”, Department of Political Sciences at the University of Cape Town;

15 Mach (Friday): 09h00 – 10h30, Seminar “AU Policy Brief on Ukrainian children under Russian control: addressing deportations, repatriation and justice”, Centre for Human Rights, University of Pretoria.

15 March (Friday): 12h00 – 13h30, Seminar “Lessons from the Ukraine war and African governments’ role in resolving the conflict”, Institute for Security Studies, Pretoria. 

Title: South African Insights on Ukraine’s Path to Peace: Regional Security, Nuclear Safety, and Human Rights Perspectives

Date: 11 March 2024

Time: 2 – 4 pm

Venue: Room 648 Department of Political Science (6th Floor, Arts Building cnr. Merriman Ave. and Ryneveld St.) Stellenbosch University


Seminar description:

The polarisation of the Russia-Ukraine war has rendered it challenging for experts to engage in substantive dialogue beyond political rhetoric. The African peace mission to Ukraine and Russia in June 2023 became the first mission from African states to address a conflict outside the African continent and demonstrate the importance of peaceful resolution in this distant war for the continent.

This event brings together South African and Ukrainian experts who have collaborated on three distinct issues underpinning the Ukraine Peace Formula: regional security, nuclear safety, and the forcible deportation of children. The event centres on extracting lessons from the conflict and exploring avenues for enhancing peace on the continent and beyond.

Title: Seminar on Regional Security Architecture, Nuclear Safety and Children’s Rights. 

Date: 12 March 2024

Time: 9.30 am – 12.30 pm

Venue: Centre of African Studies Gallery, Upper Campus, University of Cape Town


Programme:

9.30-10.30 – Regional Security Architechture

  • Prof Zwelethu Jolobe, UCT
  • Prof Tim Murithi, IJR
  • Dr Maksym Yakovlyev, NaUKMA

10.30 – 11.30 – Nuclear Safety

  • Olena Lapenko, DiXi Group

11.30 – 12.30 – Forceful Deportation of Children

  • Dr Mispa Roux, UP Centre for Human Rights
  • Oleksandra Romantsova, Centre for Civil Liberties
Title: Lessons from the Ukraine war and African governments’ role in resolving the conflict
Date: 15 Mar 2024
Time: 12:00 to 13:30 (GMT+2)

Seminar description:

Since 2022, the war in Ukraine has reverberated globally, with its impacts extending to Africa. The African Leaders Peace Mission in June 2023 highlighted the continent’s interest in finding a diplomatic solution to the conflict.

At this seminar, South African and Ukrainian experts will discuss two aspects of the challenges in the ongoing war: the international peace and security system and nuclear safety. Speakers will focus on lessons from the war, and how Africa can contribute to its peaceful resolution.


This seminar is co-hosted by the Institute for Security Studies (ISS), Institute for Justice and Reconciliation (IJR), Democratic Initiatives Foundation (DIF), Desmond and Leah Tutu Legacy Foundation (DLTLF) and the Ukrainian Association of South Africa (UAZA).

Moderator: Denys Reva, Researcher, ISS

Panelists:

  • Professor Cheryl Hendricks, Executive Director, Institute for Justice and Reconciliation, South Africa
  • Dr Maksym Yakovlyev, Head, Political Science Department, National University of Kyiv-Mohyla Academy, Ukraine
  • Priyal Singh, Senior Researcher, ISS
  • Olena Lapenko, DiXi Group, Ukraine
  • Isabel Bosman, Researcher, South African Institute of International Affairs

 

Title: South African Insights on Ukraine’s Path to Peace: Preventing Unlawful and Forcible Deportation and Transfer of Ukrainian Children to Russian Territory

Date: 15 March 2024

Time: 09h00 – 10h30

Venue: The Centre for Human Rights Lecture Hall


As of December 2023, Russian agents have taken 19 546 children from Ukraine to 57 regions of the Russian Federation: from Rostov to Murmansk, Astrakhan, Siberia, Vladivostok, as well as to Belarus and even occupied South Ossetia. Among these children, 3 790 are orphans and children deprived of parental care. Under Russian control, Ukrainian children are placed in foster families or orphanages. At least 380 minors were put under guardianship, and 31 children were adopted by Russian citizens. Simultaneously, the personal data of these children were altered, including their first name, last name, date, and place of birth. This alteration significantly complicates their identification and reunification with blood families.

The African peace mission to Ukraine and Russia provided special emphasis on returning Ukrainian children. Children “should also be returned to where they have come from, to their homes.” South African President Cyril Ramaphosa has repeatedly accentuated the importance of returning Ukrainian children, as this would be a crucial confidence-building measure.

This event brings together South African and Ukrainian experts who have collaborated in studying and exploring the topic of unlawful and forcible deportation and transfer of Ukrainian children to Russian territory, as well as the challenges that parents and caregivers face in attempts to repatriate such children. The event centres on extracting lessons from the conflict and exploring avenues for enhancing peace on the African continent as well as internationally to lead the change in developing effective measures to identify and repatriate children unlawfully and forcibly deported and transferred not only in Ukraine, but any state embroiled in armed conflict globally.


Panellists:

  • Oleksandra Romantsova, Centre for Civil Liberties
  • Dzvinka Kachur, Ukrainian Association of South Africa
  • Dr Mispa Roux,  Centre for Human Rights, UP
  • Dr Elvis Fokala, Centre for Human Rights, UP

 

The platform for expert collaborations was initiated in partnership with the Institute of Justice and Reconciliation, the Desmond and Leah Tutu Legacy Foundation, the Democratic Institute Foundation (DIF), and the Ukrainian Association of South Africa (UAZA).